Tracking Early Podcast Metrics: What Matters & What Doesn’t

Podcast Launch Series
Written By Steven Pender

The Numbers Can Be Discouraging — But They Don’t Tell the Whole Story

One of the hardest parts of launching a podcast? Looking at your first batch of stats and thinking:

“That’s it?”

It’s totally normal. Podcast growth takes time — and most shows don’t blow up overnight.

The key is learning which metrics matter early on, and which ones to stop obsessing over.

Let’s break it down.

Key Takeaways

  • Early podcast stats can feel underwhelming — but context matters.

  • Don’t fixate on download numbers alone.

  • Focus on trends, engagement, and retention over vanity metrics.

  • Track what’s working so you can make smarter content and promo decisions.

  • Use stats to guide improvements — not define your worth as a podcaster.

What You’ll See in Your Dashboard

Once you launch, your podcast host (like Buzzsprout, Podbean, or Spotify for Podcasters) will start reporting:

  • Episode downloads

  • Listener location

  • Device or app used (Spotify, Apple, etc.)

  • Listener retention (on some platforms)

  • Follows/subscribers (limited tracking)

  • Unique listeners (depending on host)

Metrics That Actually Matter (Especially Early On)

1. Downloads per Episode (Over Time)

  • Don’t panic if it’s low — most shows start slow.

  • Use it to spot growth trends: Is each episode performing better than the last?

Focus on improving your average, not chasing viral numbers.

2. Retention / Completion Rate

  • This stat shows how long people listen before dropping off.

  • Available through Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and sometimes your host.

If 70–80% are finishing your episode — you’re doing great.

3. Top Episodes (and Why They Performed Well)

  • Did a specific topic or guest do better than others?

  • What kind of title or teaser did you use?

Use this to shape future episode strategy and promos.

4. Listener Feedback & Engagement

  • Comments, messages, and emails are real signals of impact.

  • Even one DM like “This helped me so much” > 100 empty downloads.

Track what people are saying — not just how many are listening.

What Not to Obsess Over (Yet)

❌ 1. Your Global Ranking

  • Directories like Apple show “Top Charts” — but rankings are unpredictable and change constantly.

  • They’re influenced by downloads, new followers, and reviews — but also algorithmic guesswork.

Nice if you chart — but not a sign of success or failure.

❌ 2. Day 1 Downloads

  • Many new podcasters launch, refresh their feed… and feel crushed by the number they see.

  • Don’t evaluate your entire show based on a single day.

Look at 7-day and 30-day trends, not launch day alone.

❌ 3. Where Listeners Are Located

  • Interesting, but not critical (yet).

  • Once you’re monetizing or doing local outreach, this becomes more valuable.

Tools That Help You Track What Matters

Most tools are already part of your host. Don’t overcomplicate it at the beginning.

Final Thoughts

Don’t let early numbers define your show.

Focus on what matters:

  • Are you improving?

  • Are listeners staying engaged?

  • Are you reaching the right people?

Growth will come — but consistency, clarity, and community come first.

At HoneyPod, we help podcasters build shows that go the distance. And we know that metrics are just part of the picture.

Coming Up Next in the HoneyPod Podcast Launch Series:

In the next post, we’ll talk about what to do after your first 5 episodes are live — and how to keep building momentum.

✅ Subscribe to get our free episode tracker
✅ Follow us for podcast strategy tips that go beyond downloads

Steven Pender
Next

Promote Your Podcast Without Feeling Like You're Selling